top of page
  • Writer's pictureAndre Havro

Who's to Blame for the Dark Side of Social Media: Tech Giants, Parents or Us?

Who's to Blame for the Dark Side of Social Media: Tech Giants, Parents or Us?

In today's world, it's hard to picture our life without social media. These platforms have revolutionized how we communicate, learn, and behave. However, as with any powerful tool, misuse can lead to serious consequences. This raises a critical question: who is responsible for the misuse of social media? Is it the big tech companies, content creators, or the users themselves?

After reading about various government and legal efforts to regulate social media's access and impact on the younger generation, I recently had the chance to ponder this issue. 

For instance, in Florida, Governor Ron DeSantis signed a law restricting children's access to these platforms, sparking a heated debate about freedom of speech and parental supervision of their children's internet use. In Canada, schools are suing tech giants, arguing that social media detracts from learning and contributes to a mental health crisis among students. These actions represent a plea for help in the name of education and youth well-being, emphasizing the detrimental effects of compulsive social media use. Another notable case involves Seattle's public schools in the USA, which accuse tech companies of fueling a youth mental health crisis by designing platforms that encourage constant, compulsive use, particularly among children and teens.

Health authorities, including the U.S. Surgeon General and the American Psychological Association, have highlighted the dangers social media poses to young people's mental health. The connection between excessive use of these platforms and issues like depression and anxiety is increasingly concerning.

"The issues we face now with social media are similar to those we faced when television came out," says Linda Mayes, MD, chair of the Yale Child Study Center (YCSC). She explains that, as with TV watching, social media has pros and cons for young people. "So, how do we help parents filter out the parts that may be detrimental?"

Reflecting on my experiences as a digital marketer, social media user, and parent, I've always tried to responsibly manage my children's technology use by educating them about its risks and setting boundaries. I believe in leading by example and educating them to use these tools wisely and safely. The debate around social media will likely extend to artificial intelligence; the question remains whether the issue lies with the misuse or the tool itself.

Douglas Adams, the renowned British humorist and writer, once suggested that humanity might have taken a wrong turn somewhere along our evolutionary path, humorously proposing that perhaps we should never have left the treetops. This view gains traction when we consider certain behaviors prevalent in today's society. It's become a trend to blame our faults on anything but ourselves—be it radio, TV, video games, or the internet, with social media being a prime target. Yet, this leads to a fundamental question: Is the problem with the tools themselves, or how do we choose to use them? Consider the hammer analogy: it remains a mere tool until someone decides to throw it at someone's head.

The debate surrounding responsibility for social media use is complex. Technology companies are obligated to design their platforms to minimize risks, educate, and promote healthy use among all users, young and old. However, we, as marketers and parents, also bear a significant responsibility. I firmly believe that technological tools are just that—tools. Their potential danger and impact depend on how we use them. This implies that everyone has a role in ensuring the responsible use of social media. When it comes to children and teenagers, it begins with the example set at home.

Thus, it's crucial to continue discussing this topic, seeking solutions that balance freedom of expression, technological innovation, and the protection of both young and adult users. This ongoing dialogue and search for solutions should instill a sense of hope and engagement as we work towards ensuring social media spaces are safe and enriching for everyone.

How about you? How are you navigating this issue with your children, or for yourself? Let me know in the comments what your opinion is on this topic.


bottom of page