In this insightful case study, we delve into the remarkable journey of Stanley Tumbler, tracing its evolution from a traditional camping gear brand to a viral sensation on social media. Discover the innovative marketing strategies that propelled Stanley to the forefront of the lifestyle product market, capturing the hearts of a diverse audience. This study offers valuable insights for businesses aiming to adapt and thrive in today's dynamic digital landscape. Join us as we uncover the secrets behind Stanley Tumbler's astounding success and how it transformed a simple product into a coveted lifestyle icon.
TABLE OF CONTENT
5 Marketing Lessons to Learn from Stanley
In recent months, I've been captivated by the rise of the digitally ubiquitous and beloved Stanley Quencher and its spellbinding effect on a vast segment of the online population, primarily Generation Y mothers. As a marketer, I have always closely observed such internet phenomena and have followed the explosion of posts from a brand that was just typical camping gear, which is quite common among Canadians. This century-old brand, sharing its name with North America's most famous hockey trophy, suddenly went viral on social media with its emotionally supportive water bottles and strong online presence.
Affectionately nicknamed "the Quencher," this bottle has won the hearts of a loyal audience, selling out within hours of each restock. The Stanley phenomenon, a simple steel bottle with a straw and side handle, has become a social media sensation and an incredible business success story. What began as a preference among friends on Instagram in 2019 quickly turned into a viral hit, driven by digital influencer moms and popular product review accounts on Instagram and TikTok – amassing nearly 200 million views on its TikTok account as I write this article. But what's the secret, and what can you learn from it?
The Evolution of the Stanley Bottle
Before delving into the phenomenon, let's look at its history. The Stanley brand dates back to 1913, founded by William Stanley Jr., a physicist and inventor born in Brooklyn in 1858. He had no apparent relation to Frederick Arthur Stanley - The Lord Stanley of Preston, Governor General of Canada from 1888 to 1893, and creator of the Stanley Cup, awarded annually to the NHL playoffs champion.
William Stanley, who held several patents on electricity transmission, revolutionized the world of thermal bottles by patenting an all-steel vacuum bottle in the early 1900s. This marked invention stood out from the glass-insulated norm of the time, forming the foundation of the Stanley Bottle Company. William Stanley's son, Harold Stanley, also made a significant impact, working with J.P. Morgan in the 1920s to found the renowned financial firm Morgan Stanley. This name still resonates in the finance world today.
For most of its history, Stanley focused on products for men working in physically demanding environments like construction and outdoor activities. Stanley thermoses were known for their durability and ability to keep liquids hot or cold for extended periods, making them essential for workers in all kinds of weather conditions.
However, the brand saw a significant market shift over the years, adapting and redefining its target audience, especially in 2017, when it started gaining popularity among a more diverse crowd, including women and digital influencers. This transition marked a turning point for Stanley, evolving from a brand focused on durability and functionality to a lifestyle and fashion icon.
The Rise of the Stanley Brand: From Thermoses to Lifestyle Icon
The concept of a sturdy and reliable thermos is not new. Parents have been sending their kids to school with thermoses for generations. Stanley, a brand traditionally catering to workers and outdoor enthusiasts, faced criticism that its bottles sometimes leaked, a challenge for any brand aspiring for excellence. However, according to CNBC Make It data, without completely reinventing the wheel - or the bottle - Stanley saw its revenue jump from 73 million dollars in 2019 to an impressive 750 million dollars in 2023. Despite a high-quality, traditionally robust product with a lifetime warranty, this remarkable growth is a testament to the brand's adaptability and evolution.
The Influence of Social Media
The game-changer for Stanley came with the intervention of three women: Linley Hutchinson, Ashlee LeSueur, and Taylor Cannon, founders of The Buy Guide. In 2017, they highlighted the 40-ounce Stanley Quencher in an Instagram post. Quickly, the product became a favorite among their followers, but there was fear it might be discontinued. The public's response to The Buy Guide's call to save the Quencher was overwhelming, signaling to Stanley the untapped potential of the product.
When Stanley faced the possibility of discontinuing the Quencher, The Buy Guide stepped in, purchasing 10,000 units in an unprecedented wholesale partnership with the brand. This bold move resulted in rapid sales of the cups, surprising Stanley and marking the beginning of a new era for the company and the product.
The team at The Buy Guide accomplished a significant feat by securing an order of 5,000 cups directly from Stanley, a move that involved considerable financial risk. They invested their business funds and personal savings into the venture. This bold decision initially raised doubts and concerns among their peers and family members. Despite these challenges, they successfully established a storage and distribution system and launched a Shopify site to handle sales. Remarkably, their community responded enthusiastically, purchasing the entire stock within five days, a sales volume unprecedented for Stanley-PMI. Despite this success, Stanley remained skeptical about the product's market potential, suspecting market saturation. Undeterred, The Buy Guide team repeated their success, selling out once again and showcasing their unique understanding of an untapped market demographic: women. They recognized the product's potential as an everyday essential rather than just a camping accessory. This story, as narrated by Ashlee, Taylor, and Linley on their website, exemplifies their innovative approach and determination in the face of skepticism.
Stanley's Shift in Focus
Under new leadership, including Terence Reilly from PMI Worldwide, Stanley began to recognize the value and potential of the Quencher. The brand understood the importance of prioritizing the hydration category and catering to the modern consumer's lifestyle. The partnership with The Buy Guide opened doors to a new market—women between 25 and 50, a crucial economic segment responsible for a significant portion of household purchasing decisions.
According to the girls from The Buy Guide, "For Stanley-PMI, Instagram marketing was new. We knew this product was special and that we had found an audience they hadn't considered: women. We saw it as an everyday item, not just a camping item."
The Buy Guide's approach to treating the Quencher as an everyday item, not just for outdoor activities, was revolutionary. They showed Stanley how the product could fit into women's daily lives, in their homes and kitchens, not just in camping or outdoor settings.
With Stanley's entry into affiliate marketing and the strong comeback of the Quencher, the brand experienced a new wave of success. Social media, especially TikTok, where the #StanleyTumbler amassed over 2.3 billion views, played a crucial role. Consumers took control of the brand's narrative, sharing their experiences and organically authentically extending Stanley's reach.
5 Marketing Lessons to Learn from Stanley
In the dynamic marketing world, some strategies stand out for their effectiveness and originality. Stanley, a brand historically known for its sturdy, traditional thermoses, adopted an approach that offers valuable marketing lessons.
Lesson #1 The Power of Scarcity
Among the top five strategies that can be learned from Stanley, number one—embracing scarcity—deserves special attention for its remarkable efficiency.
Historically, Stanley operated under a traditional mass-production model. However, with uncertainty about future demand, the company strategically transitioned to a collection release model, characterized by limited stocks for each new launch. This change was inspired by the "sneakerhead" model, a strategy Terence Reilly perfected during his early career at the now-defunct retail chain Footaction. Rather than just adding new stock to shelves, Reilly turned restocking into a memorable event.
This concept, initially employed with great success by Nike with limited-edition releases of Air Force 1 and Air Jordans, was characterized by opening stores at midnight for launch parties, generating immense excitement among consumers. Reilly adapted this idea for the online world initially at Crocs, collaborating with pop stars Justin Bieber and Bad Bunny on limited-edition designs, and later replicating the same strategy at Stanley, where the intentional scarcity of products like the Quencher only heightened consumer frenzy.
At the height of this strategy, the waitlist for Stanley products, especially the Quencher model, grew to over 150,000 people. This phenomenon illustrates the powerful psychology behind scarcity, where the difficulty in obtaining a product combined with social media propagation as a trend among influencers exponentially increases its perceived value. "Not everyone could get a Stanley, and that's a brand's dream," said Reilly.
This extraordinary demand turned the simple purchase of a Stanley bottle into a notable feat, encouraging consumers to act quickly with each restock. The scarcity not only created a sense of urgency but also established the purchase as a privilege, a marketer's dream.
Influencers and Limited Editions
Brand influencers played a crucial role in this strategy, using their platforms to announce each restock with messages like "Buy now before it's gone!" Furthermore, each launch brought new limited-edition colors, fueling the idea that Stanley products were collectibles. This generated a vibrant secondary market for buying, selling, and trading Stanley products, with avid fans collecting multiple mugs in rare colors.
Stanley successfully transformed a useful item like a water bottle into an object of desire and collection. This phenomenon illustrates how effective marketing can alter the perception and value of a product.
In an article on Retail Dive, researcher, psychotherapist, and consultant Peter Danzig says, "Since the pandemic, research around material culture has shown an increase in the number of people who collect things. We've seen that, as a result of the pandemic, when people were isolated, they discovered the small joys they found in their day-to-day and the little things." Danzig said there's a sense of accomplishment when it comes to collecting.
Moreover, Stanley understood a fundamental marketing truth: converting an existing customer is more accessible. By creating collectible and limited products, the brand kept its existing customer base engaged and encouraged them to continue purchasing. This strategy of embracing scarcity proved to be a commercial success and a valuable marketing lesson, proving that, with the right approach, even a water bottle can become a coveted treasure.
Lesson #2 The Importance of Identifying and Capturing the Right Audience
In the quest for success in the competitive marketing world, Stanley discovered the power of expanding its target audience. Initially, the company focused on marketing its cups to the same profile of consumers who bought their adventure and camping gear, predominantly a male audience. However, assistance from the girls at The Buy Guide revealed an untapped and up-and-coming market segment: women, especially teachers, nurses, and on-the-go mothers. These consumers viewed Stanley's products as practical utensils and essential everyday accessories aligned with a healthy lifestyle.
With this new understanding, Stanley made significant changes in its market approach. The company redesigned its website, adjusted its marketing strategy, and modified its color palette to better align with the preferences and needs of this new target audience.
Stanley's experience teaches a valuable lesson: even the best products can fail if targeted at the wrong audience. Precise and targeted segmentation is crucial; trying to please everyone often fails to effectively reach anyone. For companies looking to maximize their market impact, it's essential to understand who is already buying their products, identify who they aim to reach and determine what needs to be adjusted in the marketing strategy to reach these new segments more effectively.
By recognizing and adapting to the needs of an unexplored market segment, Stanley not only expanded its customer base but also reinforced its brand as a popular choice among a broader and more diverse audience.
Lesson #3 Selling More Than Just a Water Bottle
Amid criticism and comparisons with other brands like Yeti, S'well, or Simple Modern, Stanley's products achieved an impressive 300% year-over-year increase in sales. Their secret? Focusing on selling the benefits, not just the product. While others wonder why they should pay $40 for a water bottle, Stanley and its network of influencers highlight the unique advantages their products offer.
A key to Stanley's success is its ability to turn a water bottle into a "virtuous purchase." They sell not just a container for liquids but the promise of personal transformation - becoming someone who prioritizes hydration. Moreover, Stanley products fit perfectly into cup holders, have a lifetime warranty, have aesthetically pleasing colors, and offer comfortable handling - benefits frequently praised by their devoted TikTok fans. These seemingly minor details are presented as revolutionary features, creating a perception of exclusivity and innovation.
Rather than focusing on directly competing with other brands by explaining why their cups are better or different, Stanley positions its products as if they were the only ones in the market. This marketing approach creates an aura of uniqueness and revolution around a standard product. Brand influencers reinforce this perception, highlighting the unique aspects of Stanley products without making direct comparisons to competitors.
The lesson from Stanley is clear: sell the experience and benefits, not just the product. Stanley has established a strong market presence and a loyal customer base by focusing on the transformational and exclusive aspects of their water bottles. They understand that success attracts imitators, but originality and the ability to sell a unique experience keep a brand ahead in the marketing game.
Lesson #4 Build a Community, Not Just a Product
The fourth lesson we can learn from Stanley in marketing is about creating a community around its products. Observing the #stanleymug hashtag on TikTok, there's a clear pattern: consumers are not just celebrating their acquisition of a mug but their entry into an exclusive community. However, today, many competitors have appropriated it to present comparisons with their products.
Stanley transformed the purchase of a simple product into a rite of passage into "The Sisterhood of the Stanley Tumbler," as notably dubbed by The New York Times. This phenomenon reveals that the brand has transcended the conventional idea of selling a product, moving on to selling an experience and a sense of belonging.
Owning a Stanley product means more than just having a functional water bottle; it's a status symbol within an aspirational community. For many influential and stylish women, the Stanley bottle has become a calling card demonstrating belonging to a distinguished group. For $40, consumers can feel part of a desirable lifestyle otherwise inaccessible. This demonstrates Stanley's deep understanding of consumer behavior, recognizing that people yearn for connection and identification with groups that reflect their ideals and aspirations.
Stanley shows that success in today's market goes beyond creating a quality product; it's about building a community around that product. By focusing on creating a communal experience and a sense of belonging, Stanley has managed to engage deeply and lastingly with its consumers. This marketing approach highlights the importance of understanding the aspirations and desires of the target audience, offering them not just a product but a gateway to a community they wish to be part of. Each Stanley bottle sold is an invitation to a world of style, influence, and exclusivity, proving that the real magic of marketing lies in creating a community, not just a product.
Lesson #5 Create a Customer Focused Strategy
The fifth and one of Stanley's most effective marketing strategies involves valuing and rewarding its true believers. Following the advice of the women from The Buy Guide, Stanley implemented four main changes to realign its market approach:
The company redesigned customer touchpoints (website and customer service platform), improving the consumer experience.
They introduced new modern colors that aligned with their target audience's needs.
They invested in influencer marketing and social media, recognizing the importance of these channels in the digital era.
They initiated an affiliate program, a strategic move emphasizing the significance of genuine consumer engagement.
Terence Reilly, a marketing executive at Stanley, highlighted the brand's unique approach to influencer partnerships. Rather than allocating a large budget for such alliances, Stanley rewards those "true fans" who organically speak about the products with commissions. This strategy underlines the company's belief in the value of authentic enthusiasm, which often proves more effective than traditional advertising.
Using its social listening and analytics platform, Meltwater analyzed the discussions surrounding the Stanley Cup from January 15, 2023, to January 15, 2024. During this year, the cup's mentions skyrocketed by almost 900% compared to the previous year.
The analysis highlighted a significant spike in online chatter about the cup on November 17, 2023, with over 20,600 mentions. This surge was primarily triggered by a user who shared a video showing their Stanley Quencher enduring a car fire. Remarkably, the cup still had ice in it, showcasing its exceptional insulation properties. In a response that could be considered one of the best retail public relations moves of 2023, Stanley offered to purchase a new car for the woman. The story quickly gained traction on social media and was covered by major media outlets in the US and internationally.
User-generated content (UGC) is considered one of the most powerful forms of marketing. Studies indicate that 92% of consumers trust UGC more than other forms of advertising. When integrated into a company's website and social media, UGC can increase conversions by more than six times. Other statistics reveal that 51% of millennials trust recommendations from strangers more than those from friends and family, demonstrating the impact of platforms like TikTok. Additionally, 74% of consumers base their purchasing decisions on social media posts.
The last lesson from Stanley is clear: to increase conversions, it's essential to find people who already love what you offer, encourage them to create content, and reward them for it. Through this approach, Stanley promotes its products and strengthens its community of loyal consumers. This method of direct engagement with brand fans and valuing their organic contributions establishes an effective model for other companies wishing to cultivate a genuine and lasting relationship with their customers.
How Stanley Can Address Imitation, Criticism, and Maintain Market Leadership
In light of the extraordinary success and popularity, Stanley should be prepared to navigate the challenges that accompany such acclaim. Success often breeds imitation and competition, with rivals keen to capitalize on the established market presence of a successful product by introducing similar or purportedly superior alternatives. Moreover, heightened visibility can also lead to increased scrutiny, criticism, and even the spread of misinformation or fake news about the product.
To effectively manage these challenges, Stanley should adopt a proactive and transparent approach. It's crucial for the brand to maintain the high quality and unique features of its products that originally garnered consumer trust and loyalty. By continuing to innovate and improve, Stanley can stay ahead of competitors attempting to ride on the coattails of its success. Additionally, the brand should actively communicate with its customer base, addressing any criticisms or misinformation head-on. This can be achieved through direct responses on social media, official statements, or even creative marketing campaigns that reaffirm the brand's values and the quality of its products.
Moreover, in the event of negative publicity, whether it be unwarranted criticism or fake news, Stanley should leverage its strong community support, as seen with the incident of the cup surviving a car fire and the subsequent positive PR move of offering to buy the woman a new car. Such authentic stories and gestures not only reinforce brand loyalty but also act as powerful tools to counteract any negative sentiments. By staying true to its brand promise and continuing to engage with its audience in meaningful ways, Stanley can navigate through the challenges of competition and criticism, maintaining its position as a beloved and trusted brand in the market.
Stanley's case is a notable example of how a brand can reinvent itself and thrive in an ever-changing market. By embracing the influence of social media, recognizing the importance of marketing to women, and adapting to the needs of a broader audience, Stanley has transformed a useful product into a lifestyle icon, remaining true to its promise of durability and quality.
The final takeaway from Stanley's remarkable success on social media is the importance of being prepared for success. Success often brings imitators and, unfortunately, the haters. These detractors may be troubled by your achievements and may attempt to exploit your audience with misinformation and random insults.
So, the question is, are you ready for success?